Humans survive by cooperating, and that only works with people who do their share. One person can't watch everyone, so people trade reports on who helped and who cheated.
A sinThe Book of Proverbs: "a gossip betrays a confidence".Sometimes it does. Most gossip tells people who cheats and who helps, and they need to know that.
Then and now
For 300,000 years, the people you talked about were people you lived with.
Wanting news about the people around you is completely normal.
Sources: EEA-INFO-02; EEA-SOC-15. Time scale: Hublin et al. 2017; Richter et al. 2017.Gold rings: the alarm is on
Now news and feeds add reports about strangers you'll never deal with.
The science says
Today news and feeds add an endless supply of reports about celebrities and strangers, who will never deal with you.
People now take in stories about strangers they can't punish. In conversation they still talk mostly about people they know. About 5 percent of talk is about celebrities and strangers.
Not drawn to scale. The ages and the animals are Cor's. Age adds no points to the score.
The scores
Every brain system that could explain this, oldest at the top. The longer the bar, the more of the phenomenon it explains.
What is at stakeDetails explainedDistance from the camp
00.10.20.30.40.50.60.00
420 Myr
Finding out where you standM5 Status MonitoringStanding at stake, 4 of 8 details explained, distance 2
0.43
165 Myr
One-way bonds with famous strangersM3 Social BondingStanding at stake, 1 of 8 details explained, distance 3
0.37
25 Myr
Keeping track of who to trust WinsM11 Cooperation / AllianceStanding at stake, 6 of 8 details explained, distance 2
0.50
Why it wins. Keeping track of who to trust explains 6 of the 8 details, including why cheats behave when people talk and why bans fail. One-way bonds explain 1, the sales of celebrity news.
Score = 0.571 x what is at stake (survival 1, reproduction 0.67, standing 0.33) + 0.286 x share of details explained + 0.143 x distance from the camp. Phylogenetic age adds no points; it orders the stack and settles near-ties. These scores were worked out by hand.
This phenomenon in Cor3 systems, each with its grade and age
M5Status Monitoring
Cor grade: established, rank circuit 420 million years old
In plain EnglishConstantly monitors where you stand relative to others.
The researchRank regulation. Shame, pride, submission, defeat, rank vigilance. Not optional - runs continuously.
Fully met byAcceptable position in a bounded, personally-known reference group on the order of 150 (contested). Earned prestige preferred over coerced dominance.
Cor grade: strongly supported, give and take 25 million years old wins here
In plain EnglishReciprocal exchange, cheater detection, coalitional identity.
The researchReciprocity + norm enforcement + alliance dynamics.
Fully met byTrusted reciprocal network with norm enforcement within a group small enough for direct reputation tracking, on the order of 150 (contested).